‘Nandan’ Movie Review: Sasikumar’s anti-caste film is high-hearted, but lacks subtlety and subtlety
A still from ‘Nandan’ Photo credit: Special Arrangements
It’s not often you see a film where its first shot is one of its best! Yug Saravanan NandanStarring Sasikumar, it begins with a group of upper caste men discussing the selection process for a new temple head within their ranks without considering a fair election with contestants from other communities. But Saravanan does not show us these people and instead focuses on their slippers left outside the temple premises where the current occupants of the temple expect the marginalized people to stand. As each person shares their opinion before weighing in on the other — laced with an unhealthy dose of ethnic arrogance — the camera pans from one pair of slippers to another.
Interestingly, Saravanan ends his film with a shot of a sleeper, perhaps to convey what criminals who commit heinous crimes in the name of caste-based social exclusion deserve. Unfortunately, such quality scenes are few and far between Nandan A mediocre outing
In NandanSasikumar plays Ambethkumar aka Kuz Pana — a simpleton cut from the same cloth as Chapani. 16 in Viathinil — Working in the residence of Kappulingam (Balaji Sakthivel), an upper-caste politician who enjoys the benefits of his community’s dominance over the village and his power as panchayat president. Koppulingam’s fool-proof run got into trouble when his panchayat was classified as a panchayat reserved for SCs. The former president, realizing that he has no other way to secure the position and the power that comes from it, has his minion Kuz Pana take over the post. Unsurprisingly, Ambethkumar’s dreams of doing good for his community are tossed when he learns that he is going to be a puppet in the hands of Koppulingam, who insults the new president for his arrogance.
Nandan One may be reminded of a few recent Tamil films focusing on grassroots politics. when Mamannan Perhaps the most obvious film to compare it to is, Nandan Also feelVery similar setthuman Directed by Thamiz election, which released earlier this year (the Vijay Kumar-starrer even featured a voiceover by Sasikumar). Both films have a lot of heart, but suffer from the same shallow writing and amateurish production.
Nandan (Tamil)
Director: Yug Saravanan
Cast: Sasikumar, Suruthi Periasamy, Balaji Sakthivel, Samuthirakani
Runtime: 110 minutes
Storyline: When a village panchayat is classified as a reserved one, a rich upper caste ex-president helps the new president in his oppressed house to retain power.
Saravanan opens his film with a slide that challenges them that incidents like caste oppression and arrogant display of power dynamics do not happen in today’s India. Not only does he dare to disagree with it, but he ends the film with real-life Dalit panchayat presidents lamenting how their work is hampered and their positions are not taken seriously. More than making an entertaining movie, Saravanan and Sasikumar wanted to document something unfortunately still conventional and they certainly succeeded in that endeavour. But whether the film does justice to its premise — something that needs to be addressed immediately by those in power — is a different question.
Undoubtedly, the biggest problem with Nandan This is the ‘in-your-face’ perspective. Ironically, this slant in the film also gives it its most honest and realistic moments, especially when Saravanan takes a dig at contemporary politicians. But the lack of nuance, which seems to be a product of improper translation from prose to film, kills the immersive experience the film tries to achieve. An establishing shot of Kappulingam’s bedridden father (GM Kumar) begins with a cobweb-covered walking stick. A piece of stem that Ambethkumar’s son hastily buries, becomes a plant as a metaphor for how people and their ideologies are not buried but sown. Do you get the gist?
A still from ‘Nandan’ Photo credit: Special Arrangements
There is a shot of a young man being scolded by elders for playing rummy online, and another in which Ambethkumar’s wife Selvi (Suruthi Periyasamy), a cashew vendor, is duped by rich travelers on a highway, who run for it without paying her for the product even though they are Ambethkumar’s. While these scenes may provide additional context for the clan’s quality of life, none of these scenes add any value to the film’s proceedings. Similarly, the torture porn episode feels needlessly graphic towards the end of the film’s runtime. The film jumps from one scene to another with bumps big enough to slow down cashew thieves, and Sasikumar and Surithi’s unevenly applied dark make-up is not only artificial but also reiterates misconceptions and stereotypes around the interrelationship between caste and caste. Skin tone
but Nandan There are also silver linings, such as Ambethkumar doing a trial run for the Independence Day flag hoisting ceremony complete with a salute on his red towel, which can also be explained away. red greeting Some dialogue from Nandan Not just the political satire we are reminded of in Tamil cinema, but also stands as a testament to the filmmaker’s bravery in contemporary politics; A man of high caste is spoken of “Inda puli, siruthai na namakku agdhu” (Lions and panthers are not good for us). There is also a fantastic dialogue about how people used to believe that power and authority were necessary for ruling, but the truth is, it was also necessary for survival.
The film’s accomplished cast does most of the heavy lifting. Interestingly, the film is packed with director-actors, from GM Kumar to Samuthirakani (who makes an extended cameo) to the protagonist and antagonist, and they all do a solid job. Sasikumar portrays a challenging role beautifully, and Suruthi, on the other hand Balaji Sakthivel is also building an interesting filmography as an actor. But despite their performance and a much-needed message at the core, Nandan Succumbs to mediocre writing, resulting in a predictable ending that fails to provide the catharsis the film sets us up for.
Nandan is currently playing in theatres
has been published – September 20, 2024 12:39 pm IST